Should You Buy Insurance Direct or Through an Agency?

If you have ever bought insurance in Singapore, you have probably wondered whether you could skip the agency and buy insurance direct from the insurer.

You can. For some policies, that is the sensible choice.

The two routes lead to the same insurers. What differs is how much of the work you do yourself: checking that the cover fits a contract, following an application through underwriting, chasing a claim, questioning a renewal.

Here is what an agency does, when you do not need one, and what it costs.

First, Who Is Who?

An insurer designs the policy, decides whether to accept you, and pays the claims.

An insurance agency represents one or more insurers and arranges their policies for clients. A broker is licensed differently and can approach the wider market on a client’s behalf.

IPG is an agency. That means we do not compare every policy on the market, and we cannot overrule an insurer’s underwriting or claims decision. What we can do is make sure your case is presented properly, followed up, and explained to you in plain English.

Is It Cheaper to Buy Insurance Direct?

For the insurers we represent, no. The premium is the same whether you buy direct or through us.

Buying through us does not add a charge to your premium, because most placements are remunerated by the insurer. We cannot speak for every insurer in the market, and some run their own promotions on simple policies sold online.

If you are comparing elsewhere, ask for both prices and compare the same cover on the same terms.

On larger or more complex programmes, where the work goes beyond placing a policy, an agency may charge a separate fee for scheme design, administration or sourcing. At IPG, any such fee is agreed with you in writing before the work starts.

It is always fair to ask: “How are you paid on this policy, and by whom?” You should get a clear answer.

So What Is the Real Difference?

If you are comparing the same product, with the same benefits and terms, the policy is the same whichever route you take. So are the insurer’s rules. The same underwriter assesses you and the same claims team decides your claim.

What changes is who is working with you.

Insurers have service teams, and many of them are good. An agency’s role is different: its whole job is your side of the conversation. There is a named person who knows your file, answers your questions, follows up with the insurer and tells you where things stand.

The insurance does not change. The support around it does.

What Does an Agency Actually Do?

Four things, roughly in the order you will need them.

Before you buy: checking the cover fits. A quotation answers the question that was asked. Part of our job is to check that it was the right question. That usually means reading the document that created the need in the first place, whether a lease, a client contract or a company benefits booklet, and then presenting your case to the underwriter clearly and completely.

While the policy is set up: one person who knows your file. Proposal forms, payment advice, policy documents, endorsements when something changes. One person follows the file from enquiry to policy and reads the documents when they arrive. We have caught errors in policy documents more than once.

When you claim: someone who follows up. We do not decide claims. What we do is help you submit the claim correctly, follow up with the claims team, and tell you what a status actually means. “In progress” on a portal, for example, does not by itself mean you need to pay anything.

At renewal: a second look. A renewal notice is an offer, not an instruction. We check what changed and whether the increase looks reasonable, while there is still time to do something about it.

Three Situations From Our Own Files

These are from 2026, with identifying details removed.

The gallery and the contract. A new gallery asked us for fine art and public liability insurance. Its agreement with a commercial partner required that partner to be named on the policy as an additional insured, with a waiver of subrogation in its favour. The premises lease was held by someone else again.

None of that appears on a standard proposal form. We asked for the contract clauses at the start, so the quotation could be built around the wording the gallery was obliged to have.

The family and the deductible. A family wanted a personal hospital plan to sit on top of an employer’s cover. Two questions mattered to them: would public hospitals accept the insurer’s guarantee of payment, and would the employer’s payout count towards the deductible on their own plan?

We put both to the insurer. The hospital answer came back in writing before the family applied. On the deductible, the insurer’s product summary gave a first answer, and we asked the insurer to confirm it with a worked example, so the family was not relying on our reading alone.

The application that was declined. One insurer declined a health application and confirmed it would not reconsider.

We set out two separate steps. The first was accident cover with a different insurer. That is a narrower kind of protection and does not replace hospital insurance, but it could be put in place quickly, and it was. The second was a fresh application for hospital cover elsewhere, which takes longer and depends on that insurer’s underwriting.

The first decision did not change. What the applicant could do next did.

💡 Pro Tip: If you approach an insurer directly and through an agency at the same time, the same underwriting team may receive two enquiries for one risk. Choosing one route early avoids confusion.

When Does It Make Sense to Buy Insurance Direct?

Quite often.

If the cover is simple and standard, such as a single-trip travel policy or a basic policy you can buy online in a few minutes, there is little for anyone to coordinate. The same is true if nothing depends on the wording: no lease, client contract or lender is asking for specific terms. And if you are comfortable reading a policy and following up a claim yourself, you may not need anyone in between.

If all three describe you, buying direct is a sensible choice.

Five Questions to Ask Before You Buy

If you are not sure which route suits you, these help:

  1. “Does a lease, contract or lender require specific wording or limits in this policy?”
  2. “Who will check the policy documents when they arrive?”
  3. “If a claim is delayed, who follows it up, and how do I reach them?”
  4. “Who will look at my renewal and tell me whether the increase is reasonable?”
  5. “If the insurer declines or adds an exclusion, what is my next option?”

If you can answer all five with confidence, you are well prepared whichever route you choose. If you are unsure about the wording your contract requires, who would support you in a claim, or what happens if the insurer says no, that is a good reason to ask for advice before you buy.

How IPG Can Help

IPG is a boutique insurance agency in Singapore specialising in protection for businesses, global professionals and their families.

If you are about to buy, or you already hold a policy with any insurer, we can review what you have and tell you what the cover does and does not do. If there is a better fit among the insurers we represent and our wider partner network, we will show you. If what you have is already right, we will tell you that too.

Already bought direct? You can usually appoint an agency on your existing policy with a Letter of Appointment. The policy and the premium stay the same.

To start, send us your quotation, renewal notice or the contract clause that asks for insurance. We usually reply within one working day.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to buy insurance directly from the insurer?

For the insurers we represent, the premium is the same whether you buy direct or through us. Most placements are remunerated by the insurer, so buying through an agency does not add a charge to your premium. Other insurers may price differently, so compare the same cover on the same terms.

What is the difference between an insurance agent and a broker in Singapore?

An agency represents one or more insurers and offers their products. A broker is licensed to act for the client and can approach the wider market. IPG is an agency.

Can an agency help with a policy I bought directly?

Often, yes. With your written authorisation, an insurer can usually record an agency on an existing policy. Whether and when this is possible depends on the insurer.

Will an agency get my claim approved?

No one can promise that. The insurer decides every claim under the policy terms. An agency helps you submit it correctly, follows up, and explains the outcome.

Do I pay IPG anything?

For most policies, no. Where a separate fee applies, for example on scheme design or administration for a larger programme, it is agreed in writing before any work starts.

Final coverage always depends on the insurer’s terms, exclusions and underwriting.